Serial Killer (Maniac) in Mafia: role guide

The Maniac, known as the Serial Killer in most English rule sets, plays alone against everyone. He kills one player every night and wins only as the last one standing. This guide explains the rules of the role in True Mafia and how to survive with it.

What the Maniac does at night

Every night the Maniac chooses one player to kill. He can target anyone but himself, with no other restrictions. The kill is resolved at dawn along with the mafia’s, so in the worst case two players die in the same night: one by the mafia, one by the Maniac.

During the day the Maniac has no special ability. He votes like everybody else and has to look like a harmless Townie. If the Hooker blocks him, he cannot kill that night.

In some rule sets the same idea is called a Serial Killer, a Killer or a solo killer. Do not confuse it with the Vigilante, a town-aligned role with limited shots. The Maniac belongs to nobody.

Team and win condition

The Maniac has a team of his own. He is not on the town’s side and not on the mafia’s, so both factions want him dead. He wins when he is the last player standing, or when it comes down to a final standoff: only the Maniac and at most two plain Townies remain and the Doctor is dead. The same applies when only two players are left and he is one of them. That makes it a demanding role to win with.

How the Maniac interacts with other roles

The Maniac has no allies, so every role is either a threat or a tool.

  • Detective: sees the Maniac’s exact role, so a check on you exposes you completely.
  • Doctor, Bodyguard and Lucky Townie: can all stop your kill. The Doctor acts after you, so a good Doctor might keep your target alive.
  • Hooker: blocks you for a night.
  • Vagabond: may record your visit to the victim.
  • Mafia: enemies, but they do not know you. A mafia kill can accidentally help you by removing a Detective, and your kill can help them by removing a Townie.
  • Journalist: always sees you as being on a different side from any other player.

When the Maniac appears

In the default queue the Maniac is the seventh extra role and appears from 16 players. The free version only seats 12 players, so a free group sees the Maniac only if the admins disable earlier roles in the queue, which pushes later roles into smaller games. The Maniac is enabled by default and is part of the standard setup in True Mafia Black games of 16 to 24 players. The rules table shows the line-up for each group size.

How to play the Maniac

Blend in first. In the early days a Maniac who talks like an ordinary Townie is nearly invisible. If the mafia and the town fight each other, you win by waiting.

  • Choose victims who threaten you most: the Detective if you suspect who he is, the Doctor, or the loudest accuser.
  • Think about who the mafia will kill. If they usually take the town’s leaders, you can leave the loudest accuser alive and let him spend the town’s votes for you.
  • Mind the endgame. A strong endgame is the Maniac, one mafioso and one Townie: vote with the Townie against the mafioso, then kill the Townie at night.
  • Count the survivors every day, and do not reduce the town too fast, because the mafia may reach parity before you do.