Detective (Sheriff) in Mafia: role guide

The Detective, called the Sheriff or the Cop in many rule sets, is the town’s investigator. In True Mafia he chooses every night between checking a player’s exact role and shooting that player. This is how the role works in the bot and how to play it.

What the Detective does at night

Each night the Detective gets two buttons in his private chat: check or shoot. He can use only one of them per night, on any player except himself, and he may pick the same target on consecutive nights.

A check shows the exact role of the target, not just whether he is on the mafia side. You will learn that a player is a Doctor or a Maniac, not merely “not mafia”. A shot is an ordinary kill, so there is no penalty if the target turns out to be a Townie. Chat admins can switch the shot off, in which case the Detective can only check.

The checked player gets a message that the Detective paid him a visit, without the result. If the Hooker blocks the Detective, he neither checks nor shoots that night.

Team and win condition

The Detective plays for the town and wins when every mafia member, the Don and the Maniac are dead. He is the most valuable role on the town side, which makes him the first target for the mafia. His Sergeant, if there is one, knows who he is.

How the Detective interacts with other roles

The Detective’s results depend on who else is at work that night.

  • Lawyer: if he shields a Mafia member or the Don, your check shows a Townie for that night.
  • Suicide: always reads as the Don, so a “Don” result is not proof that you found the mafia boss.
  • Mayor, Lucky Townie and Kamikaze: show their own role names.
  • Sergeant: receives a copy of every check you make, though not your shots, and takes over as Detective if you die.
  • Doctor and Bodyguard: either can stop your shot.
  • Hooker: can cancel your whole action for the night.
  • Vagabond: sees you among the visitors of your target.
  • Don: if the chat admins enabled his check, he may be hunting for you, and the player he checks is told that the Don came asking questions.
  • Shop item: a one-time item can make a mafioso or the Maniac read as a Townie.

When the Detective appears

The Detective is the second extra role in the queue, so he joins from six players. He is on by default, which means he is present in the free version, up to 12 players. A Sergeant joins him from 14 players if admins have not switched the Sergeant off. Admins can disable the Detective or his shot in /settings. The table in the rules lists the full line-up for each group size.

How to play the Detective

Stay quiet on the first day. If you announce yourself immediately, the mafia will kill you on the first night. Since you see exact roles, your information is strong, so claim the role only when it helps the town.

  • Check the players whose behavior bothers you: the loud accusers and the suspiciously silent are equally interesting.
  • Claim with proof, ideally a check that your Sergeant can confirm.
  • Use the shot rarely: when you are nearly sure, or when you expect to be killed anyway.
  • Double-check surprises. A Lawyer can make a mafioso read as a Townie for a night, so a “Townie” on a suspect deserves a second check.